Putin criticises Austrian justice system over rape case

Russia’s president Vladimir Putin has criticised Austria for acquitting an Iraqi refugee who raped a schoolboy - failing to realise that the man has not been acquitted, but had his sentence overturned due to procedural errors.

Putin criticises Austrian justice system over rape case
The Supreme Court meets in Austria's Palace of Justice. Photo: Hubertl / Wikimedia

On Monday, without naming Austria, Putin railed against what he called the “acquittal” of a refugee who was accused of raping a boy in a “European state”.

“In a European country, a child is raped by a migrant, and the court released him for two reasons: he speaks the language of the country badly, and he did not understand that the boy was a boy,” Putin said during a conference in Astrakhan, southern Russia.

“This is the result of the dissolution of traditional national values,” he said, adding that a society that cannot defend its children has no future.

Earlier this year, the 20-year-old Iraqi migrant was found guilty of serious sexual assault and rape of a minor at a swimming pool in Vienna and was sentenced to six years in jail. But in October the Supreme Court lifted the verdict of six years imprisonment and ordered a re-execution of the proceedings.

The Supreme Court found that while the verdict was “watertight” with regard to the serious sexual abuse of a juvenile, the written verdict on the second indictment, rape, cannot be sufficiently proved.

According to the Supreme Court, the first court should have ascertained whether the offender had thought that the victim agreed to the sexual act and whether Amir A. had the intention to act against the will of the boy.

The rape case therefore must go back before the regional court. In the second legal process, which presumably will take place in 2017, a new sentence must be imposed. The 20-year-old will remain in custody until then.

A Russian blog which is critical of the media reported on the developments but managed to get its facts wrong, dispensing with the legal details and criticising Austria’s “sky high tolerance” and what it referred to as an “acquittal”.

Paywall free


Tell us: What was your experience like dealing with Vienna’s MA35?

The office for immigration and citizenship in Vienna is for many immigrants their first encounter with Austrian bureaucracy. We want to hear from you about your own experience dealing with officials and the process.

Tell us: What was your experience like dealing with Vienna's MA35?

Vienna’s MA35 is a well-known office for immigrants in Austria, particularly those who live in the capital. It has received plenty of criticism for long delays, mistakes and even mistreatment of those seeking services from renewing a visa to applying for Austrian citizenship.

Yet, it is an integral part of life for immigrants and their family members, as the office is responsible for residence permits (from visas to the Anmeldebescheiningung for EU citizens), naturalisation applications and more. In short: there is no escaping it.

So, we want to hear from you: What has been your experience and importantly do you have any advice for others?