• Austria's news in English

Red Bull lost its wings

Staff reporter · 6 Oct 2014, 09:27

Published: 06 Oct 2014 09:27 GMT+02:00

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

According to Food Litigation News, a court in New York granted preliminary approval of a settlement last month relating to a class action lawsuit that alleged false advertising of its energy drinks.

Pursuant to the proposed settlement, all persons in the USA who purchased at least one Red Bull beverage dating from January 1, 2002 who submitted a valid claim could receive either a $10 reimbursement or free Red Bull products to be selected by the class member up to a $15 retail value.  Red Bull would cover shipping costs of the products.

According to the terms of the settlement (PDF), the Defendant would establish a settlement fund of $13 million in cash and free products.  Any remnants would be disbursed first in pro rata shares to any valid claimants, or if the remainder is less than $100,000, then it would be distributed in cy près to a charitable organization “mutually agreed upon by the parties.” 

The class action suit was brought in January 2013 by Benjamin Careathers in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, seeking to represent all individuals who have purchased the energy drink.

Red Bull offered the following statement in relation to the settlement: “Red Bull settled the lawsuit to avoid the cost and distraction of litigation. However, Red Bull maintains that its marketing and labeling have always been truthful and accurate, and denies any and all wrongdoing or liability.”

Careathers said he had been drinking Red Bull since 2002. The suit argues that Red Bull misleads consumers about the superiority of its products with its slogan “Red Bull gives you wings” and its claims of increased performance, concentration and reaction speed, to name a few.

This deception is proliferated through the company’s advertising on television, the Internet, social media and events, athlete endorsers, glossy print brochures, marketing campaigns and its slogan-promoting Red Bull Flugtag series, according to the suit.

“Such deceptive conduct and practices mean that [Red Bull’s] advertising and marketing is not just ‘puffery,’ but is instead deceptive and fraudulent and is therefore actionable,” the suit says.

The class action cites articles by The New York Times, Nutrition Reviews and the European Food Safety Authority Journal, which indicate that energy drinks provide their boost through caffeine alone, not guarana or any other ingredient.

The suit says that a 7 oz. cup of drip coffee contains approximately 115 to 175 milligrams of caffeine, depending on the blend, and a 12 oz. serving of Starbucks coffee costs $1.85 and “would contain far more caffeine than a regular serving of Red Bull.” An 8.4 oz. can of Red Bull contains 80 milligrams of caffeine.

“Even though there is a lack of genuine scientific support for a claim that Red Bull branded energy drinks provide any more benefit to a consumer than a cup of coffee, the Red Bull defendants persistently and pervasively market their product as a superior source of ‘energy’ worthy of a premium price over a cup of coffee or other sources of caffeine,” the suit says.

Despite Red Bull’s denial of wrongdoing, the company has voluntarily withdrawn and revised marketing claims challenged in court, according to the plaintiff’s motion.

A web site has been established for consumers of Red Bull who wish to make a claim.  The lawyers in the case are expected to receive up to US$4.75 million for their work.

Social media is abuzz with comments on this story.  On Reddit, opinions are mixed, with some claiming that the lawsuit was bogus and spurious, while others seem interested in getting their free Red Bull as part of the settlement.

"Red Bull, you have gotten me through so many long double shifts. You've given me the strength to get my ass out the door and to the bar on a friday night. Then you've graced me with fortitude to look that hangover in the face and get the day's shit done. Here, have ten of MY dollars."

"Or just keep their ten dollars because I refuse to participate in this imbecile's lawsuit. Being sued over 'gives you wings' was my joke reaction to the headline so I clicked the link to see what it was really over... and he really did sue them for it. F**k these guys and their frivolous lawsuits."

"I'm not going to join this lawsuit, either, as I feel like the product does what it claims to do: it makes me feel less tired and/or more energetic.

I drink coffee pretty much every day. Red Bull works for me when coffee alone simply isn't cutting it. I think there really is something to be said about the additional herbs and vitamins in it. The only time I'll go for an energy drink is when I'm extra tired (usually due to sleep deprivation) , and Red Bull is the only energy drink I drink. They can keep their ten bucks."

"Free red bull for buying red bull. Sweet."

For more news from Austria, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

Staff reporter (news@thelocal.com)

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Female terror suspect 'planned suicide attack' in Austria
Photo: Paul Gillingwater

Police have arrested the wife of a Chechen terror suspect after they found evidence that the pair were planning a suicide attack in Austria.

'Death must be Viennese', and not just at Halloween
Prater amusement features memento mori. Photo: Paul Gillingwater

Dominik Creazzi, "Paranormal Investigator" embossed on his jacket, strains his ears among the decaying tombstones of Vienna's central cemetery, the last resting place of three million mortals from Beethoven to "Rock Me Amadeus" singer Falco.

ECJ puts brakes on deportation of Iraqi family
Photo: ORF

An Iraqi family threatened with deportation has been granted a brief reprieve after the European Court of Justice recommended they be allowed to stay in Austria for the time being.

Flats evacuated after man swallows explosive substance
A decontamination squad was ordered in. Photo: MA 68 Lichtbildstelle

A block of flats in Vienna had to be evacuated after a suicidal resident swallowed a highly toxic and explosive substance.

'Horror clown' threatens bus driver in Vienna's Donaustadt
Pennywise, the original scary clown from the movie It. Photo: Warner Bros

A man disguised as a ‘horror clown’ threatened a bus driver in Vienna’s Donaustadt district and vandalised the bus.

Man lived with body of murdered lover for weeks

A man has been arrested in Graz after police discovered the body of his girlfriend hidden in the shower cubicle of their rented apartment.

Austrian far-right leader brands Merkel 'dangerous'
Heinz-Christian Strache. Photo: Facebook/Personal

The head of Austria's far-right Freedom Party has branded Angela Merkel Europe's most dangerous politician.

Austria 'horror clown' attacks leave several injured
Clown performers are not happy about the negative media stories. Photo: Graeme Maclean/Flickr

Several people have been injured in attacks by masked assailants dressed as 'creepy clowns' in the lead-up to Halloween.

Brunnenmarkt murder 'could have been prevented'
Locals remember the murdered woman. Photo: Wien Caritas

The random murder of a woman in Vienna could have been prevented if the homeless and mentally disturbed man who killed her had been admitted to a psychiatric institution.

Iraqi family ask ECJ to help them stay in Austria
Kumberg locals hold a vigil for the family. Photo: ORF

A group of people from Kumberg in Styria have asked the European Court of Justice (ECJ) for help in trying to stop the deportation of an Iraqi family.

12 brilliant German words you won't find in English
Sponsored Article
Last chance to vote absentee in the US elections
Five films which will change your mind about Austrian cinema
Those surprising Austrians!
100 years since the last emperor's death
Afghani family's new home in Austria
Der you learn Deutsch?
Delighted by the light
Beware these passport scams
Of course we skipped Oarsch
Foodies rejoice at the choice!
Travel & Tourism
10 years after her escape from captivity
Surviving the Brexit for British expats
Day 2 of the World Bodypainting Festival 2016
Is Islam hostile to Western society?
Bodypainting festival in southern Austria
Europe's ice cream capital
Best Austrian beauty spots
Travel & Tourism
Three days in Vienna as a tourist
How to make friends in Austria
jobs available