• Austria's news in English
 
app_header_v3

Internet relay op convicted for child porn

The Local · 5 Jul 2014, 11:47

Published: 05 Jul 2014 11:47 GMT+02:00

William W. was charged in November 2013 after police raided his home, confiscating 20 computers and assorted game consoles and Internet devices such as tablets and cell phones.

The 22-year-old defendant - who has been publicly identified in international media and court documents - was found guilty on July 1st by the regional criminal court in Graz, and was sentenced to three years of probation, as well as being required to pay €30,000 in court costs and legal fees.

The court imposed a reduced sentence, because the man waived his right to appeal.

The allegations against the man were that he operated a technical mechanism that made it possible for anonymous persons elsewhere on the Internet to conduct illegal activities - such as accessing and distributing illegal child-pornography - and that he knew it 'could' be used for such purposes.

In his defense, the IT administrator compared himself to a post office - it delivers letters, but is not responsible for the contents of those letters, because the envelopes are never opened.

The court ruled that knowledge that such an anonymous relay - known as a Tor exit node - could be used for illegal activities was sufficient for him to be convicted under section 12 of the StGB (Strafgezetzbuch) - which states that a person is legally responsible when "Not only the immediate offender commits the offense, but also anyone who intended another to carry it out, or otherwise contributes to the completion of said criminal action."

The prosecution argued that the defendant demonstrated a clear knowledge that such an anonymizing relay was likely to be used to commit such offenses, and therefore by operating the node, he was failing to prevent them - or "otherwise contributing to the completion of said criminal action."

This knowledge was based on Internet posts, where the man acknowledged that he was aware of such use. He wrote on his personal blog that the chat conversations, although real, were taken out of context.  He said “I recommended Tor to host anything anonymously, including child pornography.”  

The defendant is now facing bankruptcy, and was hospitalized with an apparently wrongly-diagnosed case of paranoid schizophrenia and PTSD.

Internet freedom advocates claim that such a ruling essentially outlaws the operation of a Tor node in Austria, as it could potentially be used to carry out illegal activities.

Previously, Austrian legal opinions have supported the view that service providers are not responsible for the transmitted content of their networks (based on Austrian e-Commerce law, as well as Directive 2000/31/EC of the European Parliament.)

Maximilian Schubert, general secretary of the Austrian association of Internet Service Providers (ISPA), explained that the court’s decision in this case will probably have no direct effect on the liability of those running Tor services.

“The decision highly depended on the special circumstances of the case and particularly on the statements of the defendant which were seen by the court as encouraging the use of Tor services and its servers for the dissemination of child sexual abuse material. We are thus positive that it cannot be seen as a general ruling against Tor services,” Schubert said.

The case however has highlighted legal challenges, he is reported to have said by PC World.

“It still remains to be seen how the Austrian courts proceed in this issue. The decision was a very unfortunate one as it might cause misunderstandings as to the responsibility for running Tor services, when leaving aside the particular circumstances of the case at hand,” Schubert said.

Story continues below…

ISPA however is positive that Austrian courts will follow the reasoning of the Austrian Constitutional Court, which last month declared the country’s data protection law unconstitutional because it violates fundamental privacy rights.

The Constitutional Court held that privacy and especially the secrecy of communication on the Internet have to be protected, Schubert said, adding that he expects that because of this ruling the legality of running Tor services will not be challenged.

Photo: TOR Project

Tor (The Onion Router) is an Internet technology that was developed by the US Navy in 2002 to protect the anonymity of political dissidents, gain access to censored information, and to organize proscribed political activities free from authoritarian interference.

Tor has been a particular target of monitoring by the NSA, according to recent reports from German public broadcaster ARD.

For more news from Austria, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Tenants in Vienna may be overpaying rent by €8 million
Wohnservice Wien

Tenants in Vienna are paying around €8 million too much for their homes, according to an organisation that monitors rent in the city.

Fireman dies in Austria on flooding call out
Photo: ORF screengrab

A fireman has died in Austria while out on an emergency call battling the fallout from severe storms in the Tyrol region over the weekend.

Batman takes on 'corrupt bureaucrats' in Austrian town
Michielverbeek/Wikimedia/Facebook

Residents of a small Austrian town get their own local superhero after 'Batman' announces his arrival to mayor.

Freedom Party claims election fraud rife
Heinz-Christian Strache. Photo: FPÖ

Austria's far-right is probing "countless" cases of fraud in last week's presidential election that saw its candidate lose by a narrow margin, the party chief was quoted as saying on Sunday.

Neo-Nazi arrested after asylum-seeker threats
Photo: BMI, Gregor Wenda

Austrian police commandos have arrested a suspected neo-Nazi who allegedly threatened to massacre asylum-seekers, recovering several weapons and ammunition at his home, police said Sunday.

Storms batter Upper and Lower Austria overnight
Photo: Fire brigade Bad Ischl

Violent storms in parts of Austria on Saturday night caused travel disruptions, flooding and several fires lit by lightning strikes, according to fire and rescue teams in Upper and Lower Austria.

Fresh attempt to seize Hitler's birth house
Austria's government submitted Friday a law to seize the house where Hitler was born, in a bid to stop the building becoming a neo-Nazi shrine.

Austria's government submitted Friday a law to seize the house where Hitler was born, in a bid to stop the building becoming a neo-Nazi shrine.

Murder-suicide in Braunau am Inn, birthplace of Hitler
Photo: Stadtamt Braunau am Inn

A small Upper Austrian town best known for being the birthplace of Adolf Hitler has apparently witnessed a murder-suicide on Friday afternoon.

Young Austrian millionaire dies after falling from window
Monaco, where the incident happened. Photo: Tobi 87/Wikimedia

The mysterious death of a 43-year-old Austrian millionaire is being investigated by authorities after he fell from a window of his luxury home in Monaco.

Weekend promises both hailstones and sunshine
Strandbad Alte Donau. Photo: Stadt Wien

Depending on where you are in Austria this weekend, expect either thunderstorms or 31 degree sunshine.

Sponsored Article
Eat, learn, live: unforgettable holidays in France
Politics
Austria's choice for a new president
Sponsored Article
Why you should attend an international job fair
Politics
Profile on Norbert Hofer, Freedom Party Presidential Candidate
Politics
Austrian politics explained. TL;DR: worry not.
Features
Refugees need practical help
Lifestyle
All you need to know about Austrian Faschingskrapfen
Lifestyle
Why looking good on the ski slopes has never been easier
Lifestyle
Live in Austria? You might develop some of these weird habits
National
How 'Silent Night' rules the carol world
Lifestyle
How a chance meeting on the slopes led to a new business
Lifestyle
What it means to be human
Technology
How a town became a green icon
Lifestyle
Why Austria has the world's best ski resort
Lifestyle
Let them eat cake!
Lifestyle
Top tips for partying like an Austrian
Culture
Five places to learn how to cook Viennese cuisine
Lifestyle
How living in Austria will improve your lifestyle
Lifestyle
Backstage at the World Beard and Moustache Championship
Gallery
Up to 60,000 people welcomed refugees in Vienna
Culture
Can you spot an Austrian?
Lifestyle
Our pick of Vienna's best vegetarian restaurants
Analysis & Opinion
Italy's South Tyrol: where an identity crisis lingers
2,479
jobs available